Why do we believe what we believe?

Three mechanisms combine. The first is that our reasoning probably did not evolve to find the truth alone, but to argue in groups. Researchers Hugo Mercier and Dan Sperber documented the asymmetry that follows: we are remarkably partisan when we produce arguments, and remarkably demanding when we evaluate other people’s.

The second is what neuroscientists call the interpreter. Our brain continuously manufactures coherent explanations of what we do, delivered with total confidence, including when it has no access to the real cause. The reasons we give for our positions are often reconstructions produced after the fact.

The third, from Dan Kahan’s work, is identity-protective cognition: on politically charged subjects, the people most skilled at scientific reasoning are not the least biased, they are the most polarized. They mobilize their cognitive abilities to defend their camp. In short: we believe what seems simple to us, what makes us feel good, what confirms our identity, what helps us make sense of things, guide our behavior and belong socially.

Practical consequence for a debate: discussing the justifications of a belief is not very effective, because they are not what holds it up. It is better to look for what that belief does for the person, in terms of identity, explanation, or emotional regulation.

Watch

Why you are not logicalThe argumentative theory of reasoning: why we reason better together than alone, and what it means for collective intelligence.Debatology on YouTube

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.