In what sense is regenerative debate still a debate?

Because it bears on a real disagreement and does not seek to make it disappear.

The confusion comes from a shortcut: regenerative supposedly means nice, consensual, depoliticized. It is the opposite. A regenerative debate can be difficult, highly emotional, and end on a complete disagreement. The debate scale does not separate aggressive debate from courteous debate. A tolerant debate is perfectly courteous and leads nowhere.

What distinguishes regenerative debate is that it allows the participants to deal together with what concerns them, where degenerative debate makes them incapable of it. Disagreement is not softened there, it is used: it serves as raw material for producing options nobody had on arrival.

That is also what "depolarizing without depoliticizing" means. We seek to reduce hostility between people, not to reduce what is at stake between ideas. A serious political disagreement, held by people who do not dehumanize each other, is exactly the goal.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.