What is identity-protective cognition?
Identity-protective cognition refers to the fact that we tend to process information in a way that protects our membership of a group rather than bringing us closer to the truth. Dan Kahan’s work produced a particularly troubling result: on politically charged subjects, the people most skilled at numeracy and scientific reasoning are not the least biased, they are the most polarized. They mobilize their abilities to defend their camp’s position. This invalidates the idea that the problem with public debate is a deficit of information or intelligence, and that correcting it would be enough. The lever is not cognitive, it is relational: changing your mind has to stop costing you your membership of the group. Note that intellectual humility offers protection against this phenomenon, where intelligence does not.