Does debate actually change anyone’s mind?

Yes. Less often than we hope, and more often than we believe.

Political psychology long described opinions as fortresses defended to the last. That image has been qualified. The work on deep canvassing (Broockman and Kalla) shows that a single conversation, conducted with certain precise techniques, can durably reduce stubborn prejudice, with effects that hold for several months.

What counts is less the content than the manner. The exchanges that shift a position are almost never the ones where the best argument is delivered. They are the ones where you ask the other person to tell you about an experience, where you listen without correcting, where you speak in their values rather than in your own.

Two honest qualifications. Opinion change is rarely immediate and rarely visible within the exchange itself, because nobody likes to capitulate in front of witnesses. And it does not run in one direction only: entering a debate having decided that only the other person is supposed to move is the surest way to make sure nobody does.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.