Should you debate people who wish you harm?

Research on meta-perceptions is unambiguous: we massively overestimate the hostility of the opposing camp, its will to harm us and its contempt for us. That error is the main fuel of affective polarization, because we defend ourselves against a threat that is not the size we attribute to it. And it can be corrected: showing people what the other camp actually thinks reduces hostility measurably.

A second mechanism is added to it, the shadow man, which consists of waving around the opposing camp’s most extreme position as though the whole camp agreed with it. It is very effective at binding your own side together, but it makes any cooperation impossible.

If hostility persists despite correcting these false perceptions, a regenerative debate remains technically possible, but the safety dimension of the setup has to be taken seriously. Not everyone is Daryl Davis, who decided to go and meet the KKK while they pointed weapons at him. He did come through it in the end, built relationships with them, and even talked a large number of them out of the movement through conversation alone, but he took a risk that could certainly have ended badly. What to take from it is that quality contact, repeated over time, durably reduces prejudice and therefore inter-group hostility.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.