What do you do when you are asked to prove a negative?

Turn the question around without aggression. "I will tell you what would change my mind, and I would like to know what would change yours." That question does two things. It reveals whether the belief is falsifiable, which is the most useful information in the exchange. And it is symmetrical: you have to answer it too, which makes it acceptable.

Move toward what the belief provides. An unverifiable claim is almost never held for reasons of evidence. Asking what it explains, what it protects, or at what moment the person shifted, puts you in front of the real issue.

Spell out the rule without discrediting your counterpart. "I cannot prove that it does not exist, nobody can prove that sort of thing. That is why we ask instead what supports the claim", framed as a shared constraint rather than as a reproach.

What does not work: saying that the burden of proof is on them, which drags you into a battle of positions that convinces nobody.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.