How do you revive a debate that is too consensual?
A debate that is too consensual is rarely a debate where everyone agrees. It is a debate where the disagreements are not being said.
The most frequent cause is a deficit of psychological safety. Without it you get silence or false agreement, and real disagreements move elsewhere, into the corridor, after the meeting. The second cause is pluralistic ignorance: everyone keeps their objection to themselves, thinking they are the only one who has it.
Four ways to revive a consensual debate.
Ask for the objection rather than the opinion. "What could make this idea fail?" is infinitely more productive than "does anyone disagree?", which nobody ever answers.
Assign the role. Explicitly asking someone to defend the opposing position removes the social cost of the objection, since it is no longer theirs.
Start with yourself. If the person with the most authority in the room names a limit in their own position, everyone understands that it is allowed. That is what builds psychological safety, and nothing else does it as fast.
Collect before discussing. Having everyone write down their reservations before any spoken exchange neutralizes the conformity effect.
And check the question itself. A question to which only one answer is reasonable will never produce a debate.