How do you deal with a false dilemma?

A false dilemma presents two options as though they were the only ones available, when others exist. It works because it simplifies, and because it forces you to pick a side before thinking.

The response consists of adding, not denouncing.

Name the third option, concretely. "There is also the possibility of..." An option named does more work than ten minutes of explanation about the logical structure of the trap.

Refuse the choice while explaining why, without accusing. "I do not think we have to choose between the two, and here is what makes me think so."

Go back up to what both options are trying to achieve. This is the most useful technique, because a false dilemma is almost always a dilemma about means presented as a dilemma about ends. "We both want this to work. The question is how, and there are more than two paths."

You can also widen the view beyond the two options and the two camps defending them: what other positions exist on the subject, and what would you keep from each? That is the approach of the synthesis man, which looks for a third story that can bring everyone’s views together.

One honest qualification. Some dilemmas are real, and systematically refusing to choose is a way of dodging. If you do not see a third way, say so: "I do not see another option either, and that is what makes this subject difficult." That sentence costs you little and makes you credible.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.