How do you deal with a Gish gallop?

The Gish gallop (mille-feuille argumentatif) consists of stringing together a large number of claims, often fragile ones, faster than the other person can deal with them. The aim is not to convince you point by point, it is to saturate you.

First thing to understand: you will not win by answering point by point. Brandolini’s law guarantees that refuting costs far more than producing. Sorting the claims, picking one, calling out the tactic, all of that stays inside your counterpart’s game and persuades almost nobody.

Change plane. Stop discussing the justification of the beliefs and get interested in what they do for the person. "I hear all your arguments. What I am wondering is what difference believing it makes for you. Does it explain things you observe? Why does it matter so much to you?"

A gentler route to the same place consists of asking for the tipping point: "there was a time when you did not think this, and then you started looking into it. When did that happen?" That founding moment almost always contains a strong motivation that explains the capacity for justification after the fact.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.