What is a synthesis man argument?
The synthesis man (homme synthèse) goes one step beyond the steel man. It acknowledges the valid point in the opposing position, points out a limit in your own view, and proposes a formulation that integrates both. It also looks beyond the two camps that make themselves heard, toward every possible position on the subject, in order to integrate them: this is ideological combination. The approach was first popularized by the Harvard Negotiation Project under the name "the third story". More recently, the Habermas Machine, a mediating artificial intelligence, tested it at scale: participants preferred its restatements to those of human mediators. It is the characteristic figure of regenerative debate, because it turns disagreement into material rather than into an obstacle. See also straw man, shadow man, steel man, silk man.