What is a shadow man argument?
The shadow man (homme de l’ombre) consists of restating the opposing position by amplifying it to its most extreme and most threatening version, in order to mobilize fear, or of attributing the worst possible intentions to the other side. Where the straw man distorts downward in order to win easily, the shadow man distorts upward in order to frighten. You wave your opponents’ most radical position around and imply that their whole camp agrees with it. This sweeping generalization has a precise function: it binds your allies together, and it makes any cooperation with the other camp impossible. It is a signature of degenerative debate. Example: "you back-to-the-office people just want to bring back old-fashioned surveillance." See also straw man, steel man, silk man, synthesis man.