What is a steel man (steelman) argument?
The steel man (also written steelman; homme de fer in French) consists of restating the other person’s position in the strongest possible version, until they tell you "yes, that is exactly it, and better than I would have put it myself". It is the opposite operation to the straw man, theorized more recently in skeptic communities as a way of defusing our tendency to caricature. The restatement becomes a gift, and the debate that follows finally bears on the most defensible version of each position. It is what you find in a tolerant debate. A warning: the steel man requires real effort to understand. An approximate version is spotted immediately and produces the opposite effect. See also silk man and synthesis man, which go further.