What is a straw man (strawman) argument?

The straw man (also written strawman; homme de paille in French) consists of restating the other person’s position in its weakest and least defensible version, then triumphing over that doctored version. The figure is an old one, inherited from seventeenth-century texts where it refers to a fake opponent built to be knocked down. It is the most widespread reflex in debate, and it is comfortable because it saves you from having to understand. Example: "so you [the remote-work supporter] never want us to see each other again, is that it?", when nobody said any such thing. Its cost is double: you do not persuade the person, who does not recognize themselves in what you said, and you miss their real argument. It is the typical argument of sterile debate. See also steel man, which is the opposite operation.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.