What is a silk man argument?
The silk man (homme de soie) is a variant of the steel man, particularly effective when tension is high. It is no longer about restating the other person’s position, but about restating your own using your counterpart’s moral values, something they have lived through, or an intuition that speaks to them. It also means using words in the sense the other person gives them, rather than arguing about definitions. This is what Matthew Feinberg and Robb Willer documented under the name moral re.framing: an argument translated into the moral language of the listener is significantly more effective than a standard argument. You find it in restorative debates. The phrase "silk man" is a coinage we propose. See also moral re.framing and moral foundations theory.