Should you debate all the time?

No, and that is one of the reasons debates go badly.

A debate requires conditions: time, mental availability, a minimal frame, and a common goal however modest. Most disagreements do not arise under those conditions. They come up at the end of a meal, between two meetings, in a moment of tiredness, or in writing at eleven at night. Engaging in a substantive exchange there pretty much guarantees failure, and the cost of that failure falls on the relationship.

Postponing is not fleeing, provided you say so. "What you are saying matters to me, and I am not in a state to deal with it properly right now. Can we come back to it on Thursday?" That sentence does two things: it signals that the subject is taken seriously, and it protects the exchange to come.

There are also moments when the relationship comes first, when nobody is expecting a debate, and where starting one amounts to confiscating a shared moment.

The practical rule fits in one sentence: choosing the moment does more for the quality of a debate than choosing your arguments.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.