Should you debate intolerant people?

Yes, and this is precisely the case where respect stops being a moral question and becomes a question of effectiveness.

Nobody is asking you to respect the conclusions of an intolerant person. We respect perspectives, not conclusions. We respect the paths, the lived experiences, the events that shaped a person, and that implies no endorsement of what they draw from them.

The reason to do it is simple: being intolerant toward people who hold intolerant ideas locks them into an increasingly intolerant spiral. The more people we place in that category, the larger it grows, and the more it risks becoming a majority we refuse to debate with, which makes any collective effort impossible. So: do not tolerate the conclusions, but tolerate the perspectives and the people who live them.

The paradox of tolerance, as Popper formulated it, does not require banning intolerant movements as a matter of principle: it requires fighting them by argument for as long as that is possible, and holds that we owe them nothing once they refuse debate and answer with violence. But even when we owe them nothing, continuing the debate may be more effective than going into battle. In other circumstances it will unfortunately be more effective to break off dialogue and fight, or to break it off temporarily because the frame is wrong and it will be resumed elsewhere, later, in a frame more conducive to regenerative debate.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.