Does the setting of a debate matter?
Yes. The place and the format determine a large part of the outcome, before anyone has even spoken.
Some environments make regenerative debate close to impossible. Short, public, written exchanges are the least favorable: context disappears, tone cannot be read, statements are taken out of context, a wider audience turns every sentence into a public stand, and the presence of your own side pushes you to speak for them rather than to the person in front of you. The three-minute television slot adds the constraint of the clock, which rewards the soundbite and punishes nuance.
Conversely, some frames make almost anything possible: few witnesses, time, a relationship that will continue, and a shared reason to get somewhere.
The practical consequence is that it is often better to move a conversation than to win it. Suggesting you talk about it elsewhere, in person, in a small group, one to one, is not a dodge. It is the choice with the best ratio of effort to effect.
And when you cannot change the place, change the goal. In a public thread, the person you are addressing is almost never the one replying to you, it is the silent readers. The more you come across as competent, sincere and compassionate, the more you gain in quality of debate and in approval from the audience.