Is it worth debating when you have lost hope?

Fatalism often rests on a distorted perception. Our meta-perceptions, meaning the idea we form of what the other camp thinks of us, are massively wrong and systematically wrong in the direction of the worst. We greatly overestimate how much others hate us and want us to lose. That error feeds exactly the discouragement you are feeling, and it is corrected by encounter.

Second, the data on opinion change is more encouraging than people think. A well-conducted twenty-minute conversation durably reduces stubborn prejudice. It is not frequent, but it is not rare either.

That said, there are moments when you no longer have the resources, and it is legitimate not to engage. Regenerative debate requires availability, and availability cannot be produced on demand. It is, however, a capacity that is built through competence. The more capable I feel of doing it, the more I want to do it. So if you deliberately work on your skills as a debater, it will be easier to engage productively in the exercise, even when it is hard.

One suggestion, if you want to keep going without exhausting yourself: lower the stakes rather than the frequency. Practice where little is at stake, with people you like, on minor disagreements. That is what rebuilds the capacity, not the big confrontations.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.