How do you unblock a debate that is going round in circles?

A debate going round in circles almost always signals a mismatch between the people in it.

Four possible causes, with their solutions.

A disagreement about definitions. You are not using words in the same sense. Solution: "what do you mean by that word?"

A disagreement about values disguised as a disagreement about facts. You are countering with studies when the real dispute is about what you value. Solution: "let us suppose your figure is right and mine is too. How could we explain that?"

A justification loop. Each of you piles up reasons, nothing changes anyone’s mind. Solution: drop the justifications and go to the motivation. "What difference does being convinced of that make for you?" Or ask for the tipping point: "there was a time when you did not think this. When did that happen?"

A problem of recognition. The person is repeating themselves because they do not feel heard. Solution: restate their position until they feel heard.

A fifth option can be useful: name the deadlock. "We are going round in circles, and I think we are not talking about the same thing." That can prompt a more productive restart.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.