How do you respond to a personal attack without losing credibility?

A personal attack puts you in front of what looks like a binary choice: hit back, or defend yourself. Both are potentially costly. Hitting back can create verbal escalation; going on the defensive gives the impression that the attack landed.

Assertiveness opens a third way. It consists of naming the behavior without labeling the person, then coming back to what the principle of not using personal attacks protects, rather than to the principle itself. Not "you are odious" and not "be quiet", but "we agreed to discuss ideas, which seems more interesting for everyone, and I would like us to come back to that".

Three points of detail.

Answer briefly, in one sentence, then move straight on to the substance. The longer you dwell on the attack, the more important you make it.

Do not justify yourself. Defending yourself against an accusation installs it as the subject. "On the point we were discussing, here is what I am claiming and why."

If there is an audience, it is your real counterpart, and it registers your attitude far more than your arguments. A calm response after an attack earns you more than three well-built arguments.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.