How do you adapt your strategy in a debate?

By choosing the argument according to the audience you are addressing, not according to what I subjectively find most convincing.

The stubborn debater always plays the same note, louder and louder, convinced that if the other person is not giving way it is because they have not pushed hard enough. The flexible debater has a palette, and moral foundations theory provides one: care, fairness, loyalty, authority, sanctity, liberty.

Take climate action. In the register of care, you speak of the populations hit by heatwaves. In fairness, of the unfair cost left to future generations. In loyalty, of the energy sovereignty we stop delegating to foreign powers. In authority, of respect for a regulatory framework. These are all real reasons to defend the same position.

Adapting requires two things. Having listened enough to identify what the person cares about. And accepting that you give up your favorite argument, which is harder than it sounds, because it is the one that convinced you.

Adapting is not telling everyone what they want to hear. Taking up a discourse you do not subscribe to in order to create support can cost you your credibility with everybody.

Watch

WAIT! You’re not using the right argumentArgumentative flexibility: adapting your argument to the person in front of you.Debatology on YouTube

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.