Should you attack the opposing thesis first or set out your own view?
Set out yours first, and start with what you share with your counterpart.
Attacking straight away produces three unfavorable effects. You set the exchange up as a confrontation before it has begun. You force your counterpart to defend their position, which hardens it, a well-documented phenomenon. And you deprive yourself of the information you need in order to choose your argument, since you have not yet identified what they care about.
The order that works: name the points of agreement, set out your position and the value that grounds it, admit a possible weakness, and only then take up what you think separates you.
And if the other person attacks straight away, do not follow. Restating their position in its best version before answering is the fastest way out of the register of confrontation, because nobody expects it.