Should you use logic, credibility or emotion to persuade?

There are as many paths to conviction as there are people. It is therefore difficult, if not impossible, to establish a single path that would work on everyone. What we do know is that some arguments are more persuasive than others, and the basic rhetorical triad (logic, credibility, emotion) has its full place in that. The logical argument is what gives sense to what you are putting forward. Your counterpart therefore needs all the elements to follow how your argument unfolds and see how it makes sense. This can sometimes produce a mild cognitive dissonance that calls for a larger, stronger explanation, like a replacement belief. The credibility argument is all the stronger when the credibility is carried by a source your counterpart trusts. You can embody it by building your credibility with different audiences, and you can also use sources they already find acceptable. Arguments that draw on emotion are all the stronger when they echo a shared experience, an existing bond with your counterpart and what they feel. Offer emotions that are too distant, moral considerations that are impersonal, or that concern groups your counterpart has already dehumanized, and the argument will carry far less, and may even backfire. In short, the best arguments for persuading are the ones that sit between what your audience already believes or feels and what you are trying to convince them of. The shorter the "bridge", the easier it is to cross.

Watch

Aristotle was right! (well… kind of)The psychology of persuasion, starting from Aristotle.Debatology on YouTube

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.