Should you debate someone who is lying?

Deliberate lying is rarer than people think, and you first have to rule out what looks like it. False information can be sincerely believed. An inaccurate figure may come from a source the person considers reliable. A contradiction with what they were saying last week may be a real evolution, or a reconstruction after the fact produced by a feature of our brain called the interpreter, the one that continuously manufactures coherent reasons for what we do.

When the lie is established, the strategy of rebuttal is a dead end. Brandolini’s law is unforgiving: refuting costs far more than producing false information, the one who asserts moves on, the one who corrects wears themselves out, and the audience remembers that there is a controversy.

Two options are more solid. Bypassing, which consists of installing a true and memorable piece of information rather than chasing the false one. And moving toward what the person is trying to obtain: "let us grant that figure for a moment, what does it change for you?" You will often discover that the assertion is not what is holding the position up.

Finally, if there is an audience, it is the audience you are addressing. Your composure and your precision then count for more than the number of rebuttals you manage to land.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.