Should you debate someone arguing in bad faith?

Let us start with the most frequent case: what we take for bad faith almost never is. We attribute it very quickly. The fundamental attribution error pushes us to explain other people’s positions by their character rather than by their situation, and naive realism makes us believe that anyone looking at the world correctly would reach our conclusions. A great deal of presumed bad faith is sincere conviction that has been misunderstood.

Now let us accept that it is real. It has a reason. People argue in bad faith to win, to avoid losing face, to make the other look ridiculous, sometimes because they are afraid. Those reasons can be dealt with.

The most effective method consists of presuming sincerity, and above all showing that you presume it. Your counterpart denies what they said ten minutes earlier, or maintains that two things are different when they are identical. Rather than pointing it out, be curious: "explain to me how you tell the two apart, I do not see the difference." Or move up a level: "we are not working from the same frame of reference, how could we build one together?"

What you are doing there is a golden bridge. You show that there is no risk in talking to you, and you take away from bad faith the benefit it was after. The person no longer needs to resort to it, and they never had to admit that they were.

Calling out the tactic sometimes works, but it forces the other person to admit an abuse, which adds friction. Keep it for when everything else has failed.

And if nothing moves, not debating remains an option. It is not a defeat.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.