How do you deal with a disagreement about definitions?

Deal with it early, because an unnamed disagreement about definitions produces hours of debate going round in circles.

The signal is recognizable: you are each repeating the same argument, you have the impression the other person does not want to understand, and the exchange is not moving an inch. It is almost always that a word does not cover the same thing on both sides of the debate.

One simple question. "We may not be calling the same thing by that name. What do you mean by that word?" Asked with curiosity, that question has little chance of creating a problem.

Then, three possible outcomes.

The definitions are close and the misunderstanding dissolves. That is more frequent than people think.

The definitions genuinely differ. In that case, do not try to impose yours. Agree on a provisional term for the duration of the exchange, or talk about the things rather than the word: "let us set the word aside, describe the situation you are talking about."

You can also adopt their definition for the duration of the exchange, and restate your position in their words. It is one of the ways into the silk man, and it often saves you from arguing about what words mean.

The disagreement about the definition is the disagreement. That is frequent with loaded terms, and it then has to be treated as such: "we may be discussing what this word should mean, rather than the question we started with. Is that it?"

Saying that out loud often settles half the problem.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.