How do you know whether a debate is worth having?

Do I want to debate in order to defend my ego, my honor, to show that I am right or to humiliate the other person? In that case, my motivation risks producing a sterile or even degenerative debate, one that will create more frustration than anything else. If I have the five goals of regenerative debate in mind, then I have a potentially very productive motivation for going into it.

Does the frame of the debate allow the constructive goals of regenerative debate to be achieved? If the format is too constraining, does not genuinely allow mutual understanding, and gives no space to convergence or to changing your mind, the frame probably needs renegotiating.

Am I available today? Regenerative debate requires attention and patience, and that cannot be produced on demand. If you are not in a state for it, that is information about the moment, not a failure.

Is there an audience? If so, the exchange can be worth it even when your counterpart will not move, because the people listening or reading in silence are your real counterpart. But which audience? Do you have a track record of having a favorable impact on this audience? Do you risk discrediting yourself, especially if the frame is already relatively hostile?

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.