How do you argue for a position you disagree with?

It is one of the best exercises there is, provided you do it seriously.

The method is called the steel man. It is not a matter of summarizing the opposing position acceptably, it is a matter of formulating it in the strongest possible version, until someone who holds it tells you "yes, that is exactly it, and better than I would have said it". Until you reach that point, you are not finished.

The steel man is built in three steps. Restate the position until you get that "yes, that is exactly it". Complete it with the best argument for that side, even if nobody has made it in front of you. And answer the best-defended version of the idea, rather than the way it was put.

Three questions help you get there. What lived experience does this position rest on? What legitimate moral value grounds it, among care, fairness, loyalty, authority, sanctity, liberty? And what does it explain correctly that your own position explains badly?

The exercise has three benefits. It makes you distinctly more persuasive, because you only refute well what you have understood. It almost always reveals a weakness in your own position that you had not seen. And it shifts your meta-perceptions: it is hard to go on believing that the other camp is stupid or dishonest after formulating its best argument.

One safety note. Announce what you are doing if you practice it in public, otherwise people will attribute the position to you.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.