What are the rules of a fair debate?

A fair debate is not a debate where everyone gets the same speaking time. It is a debate where the frame protects each person’s chance of being understood.

Five rules carry most of it.

The common goal is stated before starting, however modestly. Without it, everyone pursues their own and the exchange has no chance of converging.

The rules are made by those who apply them. An imposed rule is contested as soon as it gets in the way; a co-constructed rule is defended by those who wrote it.

You can stop to revise a rule that is blocking things. That is what distinguishes a living frame from a rulebook.

You restate before objecting, and you wait for the other person’s confirmation. It is the most demanding rule and the most profitable.

You attack conclusions, never people.

Two false rules, often quoted. Strictly equal speaking time: it suggests an equality of solidity between two positions that may not have it, and it is an editorial decision, not neutrality. And banning emotion: a regenerative debate can be highly emotional, what matters is that the emotion does not become the object of the dispute.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.