How do you anticipate your opponent’s counter-arguments?

By looking for them yourself, before the exchange, and with as much intellectual honesty as possible.

Useful preparation does not consist of listing the predictable objections in order to prepare answers. It consists of building the steel man of the position you are arguing against: its strongest version, formulated as someone who sincerely holds it would formulate it, taking account of what that person cares about and what they have lived through.

Then add two uncomfortable exercises. Look for the most embarrassing weakness in your own case, the one you are hoping nobody will see. And identify the legitimate moral foundation the opposing position rests on, which will tell you in what register it will answer you.

A language model is a useful training partner for this. Ask it for the steel man, then the silk man, then the weak point in your own position. It will not go easy on you, unlike the people around you.

One side effect is worth flagging. This preparation often modifies the position you were going to defend, which is the sign that it worked. Preparation that leaves you exactly where you were has mostly served to reassure you.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.