Why does debating feel harder and harder?

Because our brains have not changed in millennia while our debating arenas have changed radically.

Our debating reflexes were formed in small groups, where you knew the people you were talking to, where you had to go on living with them, and where a reputation was built over years. Vigilance toward the rival group, attention captured by threat, loyalty to your own were all useful there. In biology this is called a maladaptation: a trait that has become counterproductive in a new environment.

This new environment has three features. It puts us in contact with millions of anonymous people we will never see again. It strips statements of their context, which makes assuming bad intent automatic. And it rewards division economically, because negativity and inter-group hostility capture attention better.

On top of that comes a perception effect. A small minority produces most of the content we see, and it is more radical than average. We conclude that the other camp hates us far more than it actually does, and we defend ourselves against an overestimated threat.

So the difficulty is real, and it is not your doing. It is also reversible, because it comes down to frames we can influence and behaviors we can develop.

Watch

Save democracy, stop debates now! (or don’t)A systemic look at the quality of democratic debate and what is at stake when it breaks down.Debatology on YouTube

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.