Is there time to debate in an emergency?

Urgency is the most frequent argument against debate, and it is also the most dangerous.

The intuition is understandable: when the house is on fire, you do not organize a meeting. But it rests on a confusion between the speed of the decision and the speed of the action. A decision taken quickly and rejected by those who have to implement it produces nothing. It produces deadlock, appeals, and often a reversal. The time apparently saved is paid back later, with interest.

The work on procedural justice is clear on this point: people accept decisions that go against them if they were able to speak, if the process seemed impartial to them, and if the reasoning seems relevant. It is the care given to the process that determines whether the decision will hold.

There is a deeper problem on top of that. The great emergencies we face are coordination problems. We have the solutions, the resources and the will. What is missing is the ability to get to it together. Dealing with an emergency by removing deliberation amounts to attacking the symptom while worsening the cause.

What is true, on the other hand, is that urgency requires choosing a tighter format and a clear mandate, not giving up.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.