How do you spot and dismantle a fallacy?

Spotting a fallacy is easy, and dismantling it is almost always pointless. It is one of the most costly misunderstandings about critical thinking.

Popular culture presents critical reasoning as the art of hunting down fallacious arguments and taking opposing reasoning apart. It is the fantasy of the debater who destroys you with implacable logic. It is a trap, for two reasons.

The first is that we spot other people’s fallacies with remarkable sharpness and our own almost never. This asymmetry is documented, and it makes fallacy-hunting an exercise in self-satisfaction more than in clear-sightedness.

The second is that naming a fallacy places your counterpart at fault and obliges them to defend themselves. You get friction, rarely a retraction, never a change of mind.

By far the most common is the straw man, and its variants are best spotted in yourself first: stretching what was said to the point of absurdity, turning a nuance into an absolute position, answering the weakest argument and ignoring the rest, answering a nearby and easier question, or restating the other person’s view with something they never said. Before looking for your counterpart’s fallacies, reread your own answers with this list in mind.

What works instead: treat the fallacy as clumsiness rather than as cheating, and ask for the solid version. "If I follow you correctly, you mean that... is that it?" You get either a real argument, which gives you something to discuss, or an implicit admission that there was none, without anyone having had to acknowledge it.

Useful critical thinking is not the detection of other people’s errors, it is intellectual humility applied to yourself.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.