How do you persuade someone without putting them on the defensive?
By speaking in their values rather than in yours, and by starting with the relationship.
Most of us bring out our best argument to win a debate, the one that convinced us, and we are surprised when it has no effect. The mistake is believing that the argument that matters most to you is also the one that will reach the other person.
Moral re.framing addresses exactly this problem. Moral foundations theory describes several bases of judgment (care, fairness, loyalty, authority, sanctity, liberty) whose weight varies considerably from person to person. An argument translated into the listener’s values changes minds far more reliably than an argument framed in our own. On climate, you would speak of vulnerable populations to someone attuned to care, and of energy sovereignty to someone attuned to loyalty.
This is what we call the silk man, and there are several ways in. You can translate your position into the other person’s values, use words in the sense they give them, start from something they have lived through or from an image that already speaks to them, or ground your position in a value both sides hold.
This is not lying. It is choosing, among the sincere reasons that ground your position, the one that will land best. Flattering a discourse you do not subscribe to is something else, it is manipulation, and sometimes dangerous because of its unintended consequences.
Two prerequisites. You need to have listened long enough to identify the value system in front of you. And you need to have shown that you are not judging the person, because we filter what is said through our trust in the person saying it, before evaluating the content.
Watch
