How do you make sure a debate produces the best decision?
By taking care of the process, because the process determines both the quality of the decision and its capacity to hold over time.
Five elements count.
A clear mandate. What exactly is being decided, within what scope, and what happens to the decision afterward? The absence of an answer to the third question is what has been most disappointing in citizens’ assemblies.
Adversarial information. Not a balanced presentation, but access to the solid positions of each camp, presented by the people who hold them.
Real diversity of perspectives. The benefit of the group comes from the asymmetry of our reasoning: we are partisan when we produce arguments and demanding when we evaluate other people’s. A good debate only works if the perspectives genuinely differ.
Psychological safety. Without it you get silence or false agreement, and real disagreements are displaced instead of being dealt with.
Time to iterate and create. Most deliberations decide too early between two options nobody tried to improve.
And one counterintuitive point of method: asking someone to explain precisely how the measure they support would work reduces the extremity of their position, whereas asking them to justify it strengthens it.