What criteria are used to place a debate on the debate scale?
Each state on the debate scale is described by two criteria: the quality of the frame and the quality of the behaviors. The frame covers what was set before and during the exchange: are there rules, who made them, are they respected, was a common goal stated, did everyone get speaking time. The behaviors cover what the participants actually do: do they go after the person or after what the person said, do they restate before objecting, do they try to understand what the other has lived through, does the disagreement produce new ideas. You record what you observe, not what you assume about intentions. A single situation can fall into different states depending on the moment, and that is normal.