What is the difference between debate, dialogue and deliberation?
Three words often used interchangeably, although they describe different modes with different goals.
Dialogue seeks mutual understanding. Its success is measured by the quality of the listening, of the understanding, and sometimes of the mutual acceptance it produces.
Debate confronts arguments in order to establish what is true or what is good. It assumes an openly acknowledged disagreement, and it does not necessarily end in agreement.
Deliberation seeks a decision. It assumes a mandate, a scope, and a moment when the matter is settled.
These goals combine, and many conversations fail because the goals get mixed up with the modes. A meeting presented as a dialogue but expected to produce a decision frustrates everyone. A debate held while secretly hoping for consensus produces false agreement. Deliberation without a clear mandate produces disappointment, which is one of the lessons of the citizens’ assemblies. So the mode has to be chosen to match the goal. Debatology covers all of these modes and more, and regenerative debate is an approach that seeks to combine the best of each.