Why not simply ban some people from debating?

Because it does not work, and because it produces the opposite of the intended effect.

First a practical point: exclusion moves the problem without dealing with it. Convictions do not disappear when they stop being expressible. Researchers call this preference falsification, described by Timur Kuran: what can no longer be said hides, hardens in a closed circuit, and resurfaces elsewhere, often more forcefully and with no possible contradiction. This also explains why some shifts in opinion seem abrupt when they were prepared in silence.

Then a substantive point. Banning someone from speaking makes them the victim of an injustice, which is the best fuel you can hand to a marginal position. It also feeds the conflict entrepreneurs, whose status and income increase when hostility increases.

This does not mean that everything is equally valid or that any format will do. Choosing not to give two positions equal speaking time when they are not of equal solidity is a legitimate editorial decision. Refusing violence and threats is one too.

The useful question is the question of the frame: how do you allow everyone to take part in public debate without that having harmful consequences for public debate itself? That question is an empirical one, and Debatology proposes several possible lines of solution.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.