Does fact-checking work in a debate?
Fact-checking is necessary and it is almost never sufficient, for three distinct reasons.
The first is economic. Brandolini’s law guarantees that refuting costs an order of magnitude more energy than producing. The one who asserts moves on, the one who corrects wears themselves out, and the audience remembers that there is a controversy.
The second is cognitive. The false information that circulates best is the kind that protects a sense of belonging or explains a lived experience. Correcting the fact therefore does not necessarily lead to a change of mind.
The third is relational. A correction, however impeccable, places the other person at fault and pushes them to defend themselves. That is exactly the opposite of what is needed for them to be able to change their mind without losing face.
Two complements work better. Bypassing, studied by Granados Samayoa and Albarracín, consists of installing a true and memorable piece of information rather than chasing the false one. And moving toward motivation: asking what the belief brings the person rather than how they justify it.
Fact-checking remains indispensable as documentary work. It is simply not very effective at improving the quality of public debate, except perhaps when it is very fast and given the same prominence as the false information.