What do you do when someone cites dubious or unverifiable figures?

Do not contest the figure in the moment, you cannot win that exchange.

Three reasons for this. You do not have the source in front of you. Contesting without being able to check makes you look like the one arguing in bad faith. And Brandolini’s law works against you: producing a figure costs a second, checking it costs an hour.

Three responses work better.

Grant the figure in order to test the reasons behind it. "Since I cannot check that figure, it is hard for me to accept it. Does your whole idea rest on it, or are there other reasons, stronger ones, that make you hold your position?" You will often see that the figure does not support the conclusion it is made to carry, and that flaw is checkable live.

Steer the conversation toward what is really at stake. A figure is rarely what holds a position up, it dresses it. "Whether that figure is true or false, I imagine you did not come to believe what you believe simply because of a figure?"

Name the uncertainty without accusing. "I do not know that figure, and I have seen very different estimates on this subject. It is hard for me to decide in your favor. What I would rather know is why the conviction you are carrying matters so much to you."

And check afterward, if only out of curiosity, to understand your counterpart better. It may well come up in a future discussion.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.