How do you organize a good debate?

Most of a good debate is decided before it starts.

Four decisions taken beforehand matter more than anything you will do during. The aim first: are you trying to change the relationship between people (affective debate) or to produce a decision (deliberative debate)? A format designed for one will not produce the other. The question next: it has to be a real question, one on which reasonable people can differ, and not a position in disguise. The participants: chosen for the diversity of their actual perspectives, not for an apparent balance between camps. The frame last: rules gain enormously from being made by those who will apply them, because whoever wrote a rule defends it.

During the debate, a few practices carry most of the weight. State the common goal before starting, however modest. Encourage the sharing of lived experience. Have each person restate the other’s position before letting them object. Encourage small concessions, which demonstrate good faith. Handle breaches of the frame by naming the behavior without labeling the person.

Two frequent mistakes. Believing that courtesy is enough: a perfectly polite debate in which nobody moves is a tolerant debate, and it leads nowhere. And confusing equal speaking time with fairness, when two positions of unequal solidity given equal time suggest an equality that does not exist.

Get your document

Enter your email address and the download starts straight away.

We record your address and the document you requested so we can get back to you. No newsletter sign-up. Privacy policy.