What is asymmetric reasoning?
Asymmetric reasoning refers to the fact that we do not apply the same standard depending on whether we are producing an argument or evaluating one. In producer mode we operate like lawyers: we look for what confirms our position and we minimize what contradicts it. In evaluator mode we suddenly become rigorous, alert to flaws, able to spot a fallacy in a second. This asymmetry is described by the argumentative theory of reasoning. It has an important practical consequence: we reason far better together than alone, provided the perspectives are genuinely different and the goal is to solve a problem rather than to win.