What is the argumentative theory of reasoning?
The argumentative theory of reasoning, proposed by Hugo Mercier and Dan Sperber, argues that our capacity for reasoning did not evolve to find the truth alone in a corner, but to argue in groups. This explains a well-documented asymmetry: when we produce arguments, we are remarkably partisan and we look for what confirms what we already believe. When we evaluate other people’s arguments, we are much more demanding and lucid. This asymmetry is not a manufacturing defect. In a group where perspectives differ and where everyone is sincerely trying to solve a shared problem, it produces good results: each person pushes their best arguments and filters everyone else’s. It becomes toxic as soon as the group lacks diversity of opinion or is trying to win.
Watch
